A Few After-Thoughts on the Worship Debate

Legalism will get you three ways…

A few weeks ago I joined Pr Steven Zank for a debate on Contemporary Worship Forms at Lutheran Classical College in Casper, Wyoming. If you missed it, you can watch it here.

I was glad to be a part of it, even though I’m miserable at debates. I appreciate Pr. Zank’s encyclopedic knowledge of the history of the liturgy, and his good-natured engagement. I’m thankful to LCC and Pr Brian Stecker and On the Line for hosting and bringing this topic back to our attention.

My hope in the debate was to bring to light the danger of Contemporary Worship forms. I’ve been thinking about the content of Contemporary Christians music for a while, but I’ve mostly avoided talking about the forms.

Going back to the Praise Song Cruncher days of Table Talk Radio, we created a rubric to tease out the mysticism of the Praise Songs, a tool to help Christians identify the theological dangers of CCM. Contemporary Christian music is, after all, written by Contemporary Christians, and it’s doing the work that non-sacramental free-will theology demands. If I think you have a free but weak will, and I think all religious activity is hidden in the heart, then I’m going to build a “worship experience” that moves you.

That’s not Lutheran. It’s not Christian. And it’s not helpful.

But this debate put all that aside with the thesis.

“Resolved: For the sake of the clarity of the Gospel, Lutheran congregations should ordinarily preserve the historic orders of the Divine Service rather than adopt contemporary alternative forms, even when those alternatives are confessionally sound.”

We all admit that the “even” is doing a lot of work. The assumption of orthodox Contemporary Worship and Music is a big assumption. But as a thought experiment or debate, it’s very interesting.

If you have orthodox words and confessionally sound elements for worship, and the only thing that’s different is that contemporary forms of worship are used, are those forms in and of themselves able to carry the weight of our Lutheran doctrine and practice? I say no. Pastor Zank said yes.

(It’s important to note here that even if the forms could be helpful, that doesn’t necessarily mean we should use them. Just because contemporary worship forms could be orthodox doesn’t mean they’re helpful for the gospel. Losing this battle doesn’t mean losing the war.)

Does “Contemporary” Mean Anything?

For the debate to make any sense at all, contemporary has to mean something. Contemporary forms must confess or argue something.

My argument was that contemporary, especially understood in contrast to historic (or traditional, or liturgical) confesses a discontinuity with the past. If it doesn’t mean that, I don’t think it means anything.

The argument, then, is pretty simple. Contemporary forms say “We’re not with the past.” Lutherans don’t. I hope I said this clearly. I was, after about 20 minutes, getting tired of saying it.

This argument is, of course, supported by the Scriptures and the confessions, which confess, page after page, a continuity with the past, a joy in our theological and sacramental inheritance, and a refusal to let the insult land that we’ve done something novel, etc.

Pastor Zank was working with a different definition of contemporary. His argument was something like, “Contemporary means new, and we’ve always done new things.”

He doubled down on this a bit and, in fact, accused the rejection of Contemporary Worship to be the novelty. He brought in Francis Pieper, “The schismatics are those who require uniformity.” That’s an exciting assertion. Pastor Zank has the catalog of liturgical adjustments locked in. He’s like an encyclopedia with those things, and he’s right at home talking about them. The trouble is, it doesn’t matter.

Of course, the form of worship has been changed through history. Of course, the Reformation made major changes to the Mass. Of course, each hymnal had new forms for the divine service in them. Of course, Transfiguration was moved from August 10 to the last Sunday in Epiphany, the three-year lectionary was added to our practice, and the Nunc Dimittis moved from Vespers to after the Lord’s Supper. But to say that Luther was drafting a contemporary service, or that the common service was an exercise in contemporary forms is, at least, a stretch.

And here’s where the debate bogged down. Because we were working with different definitions of contemporary, we were mostly talking past each other. We spent a little time on the distinction between new and novel, but I failed to make the point, and that was exploited.

Thinking about it, anything is new when it starts, but novelty is something essentially new. That’s actually a helpful distinction. A baby is a new member of the family, but there’s nothing novel about her. But here’s where the trap was sprung.

Legalism: Three Traps

Pastor Zank pressed me on the definition, boundaries, and rules? “If it’s okay to have new things, how do you know what’s okay to change and what’s not? What has to stay the same for it to be traditional? What instruments are acceptable? What vestments are required? What are the rules that make something contemporary and something else not?”

This is a trap, and I knew it, but there are three traps, and I was only ready for two of them.

Trap #1: The Accusation of Legalism

The first trap is the accusation of legalism. The contemporary worship crowd basically thinks the liturgy crowd is a bunch of legalists who insist on following the rules. We’ve got our rubrics, and if you don’t follow the rubrics, you’re breaking the rules. This is why they’re always highlighting the passages from the Scripture and the Confessions about freedom and adiaphora, as if we didn’t believe in them at all.

As soon as you start drawing lines and making rules, then insisting on this or requiring that, then you’ve become the legalist that they fear. I think I was ready for that.

Trap #2: The Exploitation of Legalism

The second trap is that as soon as you draw a line, you invite exploitation. Rules, after all, are made to be broken. If you can’t have the praise band up front, is it okay to have them in the back? If you can’t use a drum kit, can you use a rhythm bass? If you have to have the Gloria, can you have the Gloria from 1492 instead of the Gloria from 1503?

Putting down any line is an invitation to logomachia, a word dispute. (See 2 Timothy 2:14.)

But the problem is that this is asking the wrong question. I remember the old youth group days when the dating couple would ask, “How far is too far?” If you’re asking the question, you’ve gone too far. If you’re looking for the cliff so you can get as close to it as possible, you’re tempting God. We’re not supposed to test the boundaries. We’re supposed to pursue and receive the gifts of God.

Here a good debater would’ve exploited the point: The fact that you are asking these question shows what’s going on underneath the surface. Instead of a humble and thankful receiving of the liturgy, the contemporizer is rejecting, refusing, rebelling. Contemporary music and forms are rebellious, especially amongst Lutherans.

I attempted a table flip: why are you asking the questions? Why are you departing from what we’ve been given? That didn’t go anywhere, which is too bad, because right here is the real issue in regards to contemporary versus traditional forms. Missing it left me open to the third trap, the surprise.

Trap #3: Legalism Excused

I should’ve seen this coming, but didn’t. No excuses. I knew I couldn’t get drawn into the legalist trap of making rules and drawing lines, but the refusal (or failure) to do this made it easy for Pr. Zank to say, “How can we keep the rules if you don’t know what they are? How can you condemn contemporary worship forms if you can’t define them? You accuse us of being emotive, but you’re using your own feelings and subjective experiences as the criteria for what’s right. If you can’t define it, then you can’t restrain us.” Legalism (or lack of legalism) excused. If there are no rules, there are no rules.

The real trap is that the rules, or lack of rules, are not the problem. The problem is the heart, the spirit, that receives or rejects what is given. I can, with a rebellious heart, keep all the rules. I can, with a humble heart, break them.

This, again, exposes the real danger brought to the church through contemporary worship: rebellion. The ancient gifts are thrown out. The old ways are forsaken. The traditions are abandoned. The liturgical connection with our fathers and mothers in the faith is severed. This is the essence of contemporary.

It is what the contemporary forms are confessing and communicating: we are not of the past. “This is not your grandma’s church.” When we plan our worship we look around, not back.

Pr. Zank, I believe, would contest this assertion, promising that you can be contemporary without being rebellious. I would thank him for this assertion, and ask for proof. Or even an attempt to prove it. I think I’d be content with the argument, but I think Pr. Zank might be the only person in the world that is interested in making it, mostly because it would sound, to every other contemporary church musician, like saying, “Let’s do not-contemporary contemporary worship.” Or you could just do what the church has always done.

The Invocation Example

But there is no “we’ve always done it that way.” So Zank argues, and I’m thinking specifically about the example he offered about the Invocation, how the drafters of the Common Service add the invocation to the beginning of the service. I didn’t know that, and it is an interesting bit of history.

In the debate I tracked back the history of the Invocation to the catechism and the deep tradition of the church, noting that it was considered an ancient practice already in the time of Tertullian, but I was thinking in the wrong direction. Instead of looking back, I should’ve looked forward. I should’ve asked, “If the drafters of the Common Service planned to use the Invocation on the first week, what were they going to use on the second week? What would the change on the third week? How would they start the service the week after that?” This, of course, is absurd. They were not changing things for the sake of changing. They were not innovating for the sake of innovation. They did not consider their project a temporary one. The parts of the service were not plastic forks or paper places to be used once and thrown away. The Invocation was finding a new home in the beginning of the service, where it has lived for generation. Praise the Lord.

This difference helps highlight the difference between previous liturgical adjustments and the contemporary worship.

Not Wrong in Not Enough

There is a big difference between being “not wrong” and being “right.” “There is no false doctrine” is not the same as “this confesses the truth of the Lord’s Word.” Contemporary Worship often flies under the radar of “no false doctrine” by not having any doctrine at all. But even true doctrine does not mean the full truth of God’s is being confessed. All Law means no Gospel. All praise means no prayer. All teaching means no absolving.

It is true that the instructions for worship given to Moses are much more detailed that the liturgical instructions of the New Testament, but the “build what you have seen” rubric still stands (see, for example, Exodus 25:9, Acts 7:44, Hebrews 8:1-5). Our liturgy on earth is to be a shadow and reflections of what’s happening in the heavenly throne room.

Praise happens there, but also conversation, hearing prayer, sending forth servants, and most especially the heavenly court. This heavenly court is the outline of the Divine Service. We enter the service and make our plea: guilty. We hear the divine verdict in the absolution, the explanation in the Word and Preaching, and we eat and drink the evidence of Christ’s body and blood which are presented before the heavenly altar. Christ’s atoning work on the cross prevails in the heavenly court, and the divine service carries that gift to us sinners here on earth.

Contemporary forms not only fail by being wrong, but by being incomplete. It diminishes the council of God.

I should’ve mentioned that.

Instruments also Have a Confession

Here’s where I failed the most, both in what was said and left unsaid. My story about the ancestor-worshipping drums in Fiji, a way of saying the drum-set is pagan without saying it, was, rightly, dismissed as a completely subjective point, and was used to invite compassion for people with similar subjective troubles, like the people traumatized by the organ.

But I further failed to articulate that instruments, like contemporary forms, communicate something. Bagpipes are coded for Scotland, war, and funerals. Kazoos are silly. Castanets invoke Spanish dancers. The saxophone reminds us of Kenny G or that guy who would show up in supermarkets that went viral on the internet. The drum-kit and its back-beat, especially when the altar is moved to the side so there’s room for the drummer, confesses something.

Lots of people know a lot more about this than me, and I hope they will be able to join in the conversation, but all of us can recognize instruments communicate something even before they make a sound, and we want to be careful not to communicate the wrong thing. Instrumentation matters.

Salvation’s Long Old Road

Praise the Lord that He has been saving people for a long time. The Word and the Sacraments have been brining the benefit of the death of Jesus to His people since He Himself preached the Gospel in Genesis 3:15. This is nothing new, and never will be.

When the Lord gathers His people to visit and bless them He’s doing what He’s always done, and always will do. It’s not contemporary, or even temporary, but eternal. May God grant us the humble spirit to rejoice in this. Amen.

Christ is Risen! PrBW

Pastor Bryan Wolfmueller
Bryan Wolfmueller, pastor of St Paul and Jesus Deaf Lutheran Churches in Austin, TX, author of "A Martyr's Faith for a Faithless World", "Has American Christianity Failed?", co-host of Table Talk Radio, teacher of Grappling with the Text, and theological adventure traveler.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *